lotsoftools

Understanding Rust Error E0034: Overlapping Method Signatures

Introduction to Rust Error E0034

Rust Error E0034 occurs when the compiler encounters a situation where more than one method has the same prototype in a given implementation. This can lead to ambiguity as the compiler does not know which method to call. This error is typically seen when implementing multiple traits with the same method signatures for a single struct.

Example of Rust Error E0034

struct Test;

trait Trait1 {
    fn foo();
}

trait Trait2 {
    fn foo();
}

impl Trait1 for Test { fn foo() {} }
impl Trait2 for Test { fn foo() {} }

fn main() {
    Test::foo() // error, which foo() to call?
}

How to Resolve Rust Error E0034

To fix Rust Error E0034, you can choose from several approaches. One possible solution is to keep only one of the conflicting methods and remove the others. However, a more elegant solution would be to use fully explicit naming to disambiguate method calls, as shown below:

struct Test;

trait Trait1 {
    fn foo();
}

trait Trait2 {
    fn foo();
}

impl Trait1 for Test { fn foo() {} }
impl Trait2 for Test { fn foo() {} }

fn main() {
    <Test as Trait1>::foo();
}

In this example, we have explicitly specified the trait when calling the foo() function, avoiding confusion for the compiler.

Another Example for Rust Error E0034 Resolution

trait F {
    fn m(&self);
}

trait G {
    fn m(&self);
}

struct X;

impl F for X { fn m(&self) { println!("I am F"); } }
impl G for X { fn m(&self) { println!("I am G"); } }

fn main() {
    let f = X;

    F::m(&f); // it displays "I am F"
    G::m(&f); // it displays "I am G"
}

In this example, we have two traits, F and G, both with the same method signature for m(). By explicitly specifying the trait when calling m(), we disambiguate these calls, successfully resolving the E0034 error.

Recommended Reading